• Recordings
• Meeting Notes
• Big Items Up Front
• Beanstalk Project Funnel
• wstETH Migration/ Multi Flow V1.1.0/ Misc Improvements
• Beanstalk 3
• Is there a usage for a Well that is not Whitelisted?
• Subgraph updates
• UI updates
• Are there plans to integrate with other DeFi protocols
• Transcript

Recordings

Meeting Notes

Big Items Up Front

• BIP-45,46 and 47 have all passed! Temp Check 4 and 5 ended!
• Beanstalk 3 audit is underway

Beanstalk Project Funnel

• L2 migration is still in the discussion period, and there will be more info over the next couple weeks

wstETH Migration/ Multi Flow V1.1.0/ Misc Improvements

• These are all currently in remediation from the Codehawks audit
• Rex mentions that it is unclear how these improvements will directly help Farmers
• Pizzaman mentions that wstETH grows over time as ETH pays out its staking rewards. If ETH stays flat over a period of time wstETH will be valued more because of the staking rewards.
• Misc improvements have a lot of various updates that "clean up" Beanstalk. They will make the protocol easier to use. The Chop rate will increase to around 5% with this update.

Beanstalk 3

• Beanstalk 3 has a lot of various updates all included in one bigger update. Rex mentions that the auditors are really engaged. Pizzaman mentions that things are going really well with the audit.
• Tractor will allow users to create Blueprints. For example, if you want to Convert if Bean is trading below $.95 you will be able to create a Blueprint so someone can do this for you. Gen Convert will allow conversions between 2 LPs. In addition, you will be able to Convert for a Stalk penalty. Secure Beanstalk will ensure the state of Beanstalk before and after a transaction is what it should be. Solidity v8 will not affect users but it will make dev work easier. Whitelist v1.1 will make a clear path to Whitelisting a Well. There will be some sort of UI for this. There will always need to be a Stalk Vote to whitelist a Well. Gen Flood will support multiple Wells. It is really hard to say if adding more Wells is the top priority, but Rex knows that a lot of people are interested in getting that done. All of these updates generalize Beanstalk to work with multiple whitelisted Wells.

Is there a usage for a Well that is not Whitelisted?

• Rex mentions that it is dependent on a case-by-case basis. They mention that there are a lot of uses for Basin, especially when the Well is Whitelisted. There is an opportunity for a Well to be useful and not Whitelisted. SweetRedBeans mentions that the thinking behind Basin was initially to have multi-block MEV resistance.

Subgraph updates

• Soilking's main focus has been to get added to DeFiLlama. Basin is already listed on it and you can see the historical volume. They are most excited to see the Beanstalk APYs added to the site! They are going to focus on a personal APY playground to try out various amounts of Grown Stalk or other parameters.

UI updates

• SRB has been working on contextualizing the Seed Gauge. The goal of this is to allow more farmers to make more efficient transactions. Next, They will be working on making a UI for all the Beanstalk 3 updates.

Are there plans to integrate with other DeFi protocols

• SoilKing mentions that there is not currently a plan for anything, but getting Basin on DEX aggregators would be pretty cool. Rex mentions that the Beanstalk ecosystem will be much more complex and there's so much anyone can do.

Transcript

well so um just to rerun through the uh the big items up front so um had the Big Items Up Front three uh bips that were recently undervote all pass um and then the two CH temp checks finished out as well um and have the results there um when it comes to upcoming and ongoing items really we've got one big package of work um that is um that is currently in audit remediation and then beanock 3 is currently under audit with Cod Hawks so we'll dig into those a little bit more here as we get further down to the slides okay to hit the project funnel real quick um really not a whole lot of movement and items the uh probably the Beanstalk Project Funnel biggest item because it's getting more and more discussion um I know within the the contributor Community is the L2 migration and um I know so we're still in discussion phase in terms of an exact approach um that is becoming something that's becoming more and more likely so um I'd imagine we'll probably have more information about um what the uh the approach is going to be to that here over the next probably over the next couple weeks so stay tuned for that other than that no real major changes in terms of the uh the project funnel okay uh dropping down into the projects themselves um so as mentioned uh with this first handful of uh of projects um wstETH Migration/ Multi Flow V1.1.0/ Misc Improvements all these items are in um remediation and won't bother to go over um these first few projects in a lot of extra detail with the exception of if somebody has any questions they can certainly drop something in the chat or or unmute themselves and and ask um so rap Ste is uh is in remediation expecting uh completion of July 1st same thing with multiflow version 1.1.0 in the miscellaneous improvements B um so U miscellaneous improvements looking at um deployment around the week of July 15 any questions about any of those items before we jump into beanock 3 now as I see your your question oh um yeah did multiflow show that it didn't need a bip uh that is correct that is going to go uh through its deployment process with the WRA Ste deployment a lot of times for what it's worth um these groups of groups of work or what the the slides will show probably reflects um audit groups groups of code that are sent for audit probably more than um specific bips um so that's that's probably a good um understanding to why multiflow is has its own um has its own page but isn't necessarily set up with that that bip um voting period it it'll be incorporated with one point or with uh rap Tyler looking at your question right now um Tyler asked how do do we think those enhancements that are going to be deployed in July will help with the growth of the protocol it's not clear to me so um I guess what I'll do maybe the best way to uh to approach that we've got um a handful of those contributors that have been working on um these improvements on this call and um Pizza Man dead man I don't know if either you guys wanted to jump in and talk a little bit about um you know some of these items and and the new tools it'll give participants but I'll I'll open it up to you yeah so I think the first thing that's going to be deployed next is the WRA Ste uh migration with the the multiflow 1.1 and so by moving the the base token uh from the bean eth well to the bean WRA steth WRA steth you know rebases or it kind of grows over time as eth pays out it's it's staking um rewards and so theoretically as that happens uh if the price of eth stays flat uh theoretically the price of rep steth should continue to increase which is beneficial for beanock and then the the second one which is the um the miscellaneous improvements I think maybe dead man could say something about that I don't see that dead man is around now actually maybe the the time zone is not good yeah yeah oh and you know what yeah dead man is on a he's on a European time zone so um the so the miscellaneous improvements are are kind of that so um there are handful so if you look at these items so um bdv increase for metadata soil issuance update um I would say a lot of these are they're like cleanup items um so the um I would I guess I would kind of classify a lot of these miscellaneous Improvement items as um as like uh I hate to say user experience but basically they're more basic improvements to make the protocol both easier to use and and a little bit more stable I think the the probably the uh let's see yeah I think that's probably the best way to categorize them um what I can do Tyler is I can reach out to dead man and just kind of have him run through um give a short explanation of each and uh and have him drop it in the chat um to to just provide a little bit of that extra information personally I think the most interesting one here is the um the ch rate increase so it'll increase to something like around 5% given the current amount of um fertilizer that's been sold so at a 5% chop rate that becomes a lot more attractive uh than it is now so perhaps more people will chop and increased chops means reduced total amount of debt for beanock appreciate it okay any other questions before we jump into beanock 3 okay um so as we've discussed before Beanstalk 3 beanock 3 is a pretty significant um bundle of works currently under audit um so you know you've got um components of tractor generalized convert secure bean stock generalized flood and you know a handful of other smaller updates a lot of which are kind of on the back end um the I guess just watching a lot of the chats um there's been a lot of really good discussion between our team and the Auditors um so pizza man not to not to uh kind of put you on the spot but I'd love to hear your input on how that's been going I mean I I feel like just watching the chats seems like the discussion's been good the the code Hawks Auditors seem to be really engaged um asking good questions um you have any any thoughts about how the process is going yeah yeah agreed uh there's a lot of threads that's that have been started as well that are privately um where they're asking questions to the the people who wrote the code which is the beanock uh contributors here and so there's been a number of things that indicate that you know people are getting a better grasp of the protocol and really trying to find ways uh to possibly exploit it and I think we've already gotten a couple um useful reports out of that as well so I don't think anything will be disclosed until the end of the audit time uh but it's from what I've seen so far it looks like it's definitely uh been you know going pretty well appreciate that all right any other up Tyler B's typing Tyler's still typing so uh Tyler B asked the same question um about beanock 3 how do we think that it will make the protocol better Pizza Mania you want to want to throw in any thoughts on there I've got a couple myself sure sure um yeah I mean note that I'm just you know an individual contributor like you know beanock is this big thing it's not like um you know everyone has their own opinion about what what will happen or what won't happen um the only way to find out is to to find out but I can kind of talk through some of these here on the list so the top one being tractor this has been discussed for a long time U theoretically tractor will allow you to uh create These Blueprints which allows code to execute on your behalf so for example let's say you wanted to mow or convert if a certain set of conditions happen so you know let's say um if being drops below 90 cents and you know you want to convert when that happens then you can set up a blueprint that will pay someone to execute that convert on your behalf so that you don't have to uh be around for that to happen it also enables another of other a number of other um interesting things so like theoretically you could have uh Mark like deposit markets based on tractor so that all also requires a UI I'm not sure what the timeline for the UI is I do more work on the the solidity side uh but sooner or later the UI should be up and running for that as well um the next thing is generalized convert so that will right now you can only convert uh between bean and LP and you can't convert between LPS so when multiple um Wells become whitelisted they're without generalized convert there's not a way to convert between them and there's also not a way to uh convert in a way that will um give you a a stock penalty meaning so now if you if you wanted to convert um for example from Bean to the bean eth well you couldn't do it uh but with generalized convert you can there's a pre-calculated penalty that you'll get when doing so so that allows more um flexibility but also uh adds in the stock penalty to try and align align incentives then the next one is uh secure beanock so this one is really interesting uh basically whenever any action happens within beanock uh it checks the state of beanock before and after and it basically adds up all of the debt that beanock has and all of the um underlying asset ownership so you know let's say you have some beneath well uh token deposited and uh so to a bunch of other people and then you know someone tries to call a function on beanock and somehow they find a way to extract all of that uh theoretically the secure beanock code will see um at the check that happens on the back end of the function call to say like hey uh you know you're trying to extract to too of this uh underlying token that's held by beanock that it owes its users uh so it it will revert when that happens so super interesting to see you know what kind of um exploits that will prevent in the future and the next one is the uh solidity version 8 so for 0.8 this is more of a not anything like user experiencing that you user facing that you experience um but it's a great you know way to get on the latest version of solidity that has a number of great features and just keeps us up to date basically with the latest uh eth Tech then Whit list to be 1.1 this is quite interesting actually because it allows it to be a lot easier to actually Whit list other Wells so for a long time people have been wanting to Whit list you know uh wrapped Bitcoin or um you know other stable coins and that hasn't happened for a number of reasons but one of them was that uh the the code to actually whitel list was kind of a bit complicated so this will make it a lot easier for people to uh propose bips that will Whit list more assets uh the next one is Gen flood so flood um to be honest is unlikely to happen unless you know beanock experiences a rapid amount of growth however just the flood code needed to be updated in order to support multiple Wells anyway um so that was updated was a good time to to sneak it in before the audit and let's see here I think that pretty much covers everything on the list if there anything that I missed uh I'd be happy to cover it piz man I appreciate that I mean I like I feel enough Comfort even as a a non-technical contributor that I could walk through some of but you did a much better job than I would um Tyler to give you my spin on you know the uh your specific question about how we think they'll make the protocol better first I will I will reiterate what pizza man said how like we just we don't know exactly you know how users will use these tools as they're deployed um but the two that really stick out to me and this is again just my personal opinion are wh list version 1.1 and tractor I think those are um particularly interesting as we continue to talk to perspective participants um you know I know that there's a lot of discussion right now happening in the Discord about you know bring new users in and you know what are the the best ways to do that or or you know you talk about marketing or you talk about you know whatever you want um in that regard but these two particular items um will give you users a lot of new opportunities and new ways to um Leverage The protocol um you know tractor being able to create some of these more automatic U more complex transactions and have someone else execute them on your behalf potentially in groups I that's a really an interesting idea um um even just having some discussions with outside groups over the last few weeks um talked with another protocol um about Services they're offering their participants and um they were talking about you know automatic automatic trade features and and and conversions and um it is it's nice to know that tractor not only will give our users opportunities to do things like that but really I would say that we don't even really have our hands around the level of of potential uh potentially complex transactions that could be set up through tractor so that's really exciting um and then the Whit list v1.1 you know pizza man said it it'll make Whit listing new assets a lot easier getting to uh getting to to talk with some of the other contributors I think we're still a little ways away from a you know someone like me clicking a few buttons and being able to spin up a well but uh Wireless version 1.1 is a step change in terms of being able to to get those um those new well spun up so significantly easier cutting down on the the development and implementation time so you know again moving the protocol forward to really interesting um pairing options and new wells so Tyler follows up with what work is left after being St three to be able to add new wells through a UI and making the white listing super straightforward um so that's a that's a it's a bit of a complex question Tyler I wish I had a really succinct answer for you um again just based on some of the conversations that that I've been having or or been able to listen in on or or read through I think we are still a little ways away from like I said someone I use myself as example because I'm I'm non- technical uh you know being able to say hey I've got some you know some random token that's in erc20 I'd like to spin up a well um I think we're so ways away from me being able to do that just you know on my own but again the level of complexity with light Whit list uh v1.1 is significantly reduced so um it's it's a closer um opportunity and I do know that there is some type of UI that will likely go along with the white listing um I don't think it'll be again I don't think it'll be like you know here's your handful of button clicks but it will be a way to get the right information into the hands of the the contributors that and get those Wells spun up relatively quickly so again white list is a step change so space Bean just jumped into and says uh the Basin UI is to deploy well uh or I'm sorry deploy well via Basin is currently being worked on and should be up soon so that UI is under development any other questions on sorry yeah my understanding is that the white listing aspect of it will always require a a stock vote so I'm not sure that there will be a UI for that but the key inputs necessary are the actual well address and the USD Oracle which now you can also pass in with a new wh listing 1.1 uh simply by a contract address so for example if there's an existing um Oracle on chain link that has uh let's just take for example wrapped Bitcoin uh to the dollar amount then that address can be passed into to this new wh listing function so it's a lot more straightforward uh than it was before to be able to Whit list something however it needs in order for that to actually happen you know any bip is code running basically and so there needs to be code written that calls that function however any proposer could just say hey here's the you know what I want to White list um and pass in you know just in the description of the uh the proposal they could say what the address of the Oracle is and what the address of the token is that they that they would like to have white listed Y and actually pizza man you're bringing up a really good point I'm watching soil king um drop a comment in as well there's probably a distinction that we'll need to continue to remind folks there's a difference between getting a new well implemented versus getting that well whitelisted for um for uh Senor so that that's probably an important distinction that we'll continue to make um so getting a well uh implemented is you know is let's say it's and and again stop me if I'm miscon during this anybody um but as I see that that's the more technical component where pizza man like you just talked about you know getting the address determining the Oracle there's all those components and then the wh listing aspect is again you hit it right pizza man that is that's a voting component that would um that would incorporate that new well to uh to re to be part of the silo essentially and receive seniorage so there's a little bit of a distinction between those two uh those two aspects one would lead to the other but they're not they're not the exact same thing it's it's essentially a set of steps all right and looking at the chat so soil can bring up a good point so King rights for white Ling we also need to be careful which pool we white list since it will affect minting I think that's a very U it's a good observation it's absolutely true so uh Tyler B asks is creating new wells the highest priority after being stock three it's clear that we need more Wells right now we only have one so I will so soil King later on adds clarification which is important that um the WRA steep BS technically is is a second well um Tyler to to address your question specifically you know it's hard to say hey this thing is the number one priority I do know that there are a lot of folks that are very passionate about getting um new wells implemented I you know it's probably not proper to like give like a specific list of priorities I would say getting additional Wells implemented in in white listed as soon as possible is is a very high priority a lot of people are interested in getting that done let's see so looks like soil King asked a um a question back to space beam and so soil King asked uh to space beans mentioned about the Bas UI being updated with the uh the um the wh list capabilities soing ass and this will allow for any two tokens uh any two tokens in a well not just being and yep that's correct space being confirmed then sweet red basically just followed up with Tyler uh to ask uh if Tyler's asking about the ability to deploy new well in Basin or wh L wh listing new deployed Wells which again kind of goes back to what I was just talking about here a minute ago about the difference between deploying the new well and then whitelisting and the deployment being more of a kind of the technical component and the Whit list being more of a more of a governance seniorage component and we got a couple people typing in the chat yeah so the a lot of the the discussion seems to be around you know what are those what are those two things um the difference between implementation of new well and white listing so and again this Whit list version 1.1 is that progression in terms of the technical component you know so it is going to make the implementation process easier for new wells wh listing for seniorage for what it's worth that it's a little bit of a different question because like I said it has a lot to do with um it's a vote something that's voted on by the Dow it has a lot to do with what the Dow thinks about the particular assets that are going into the well so you know to just kind of toss out some potential situations I think there's there's probably a lot of interest I shouldn't say think I know there's a lot of interest from the community around doing WRA Bitcoin as well and that well implementation will have a technical component that again you know will hopefully be made quite a bit easier through wh list version 1.1 you know just improving that implementation experience the whitelisting the actual addition of that that asset or that well I should say to give it seniorage should also be relatively straightforward um obviously bitcoin's an it's extremely well-known asset um well trusted there probably won't be a lot of uhu there may be some questions but there's a lot of faith in the stability and General Security of Bitcoin so WAP Bitcoin is kind of an obvious choice um where I think there'll be a lot more interesting discussion is as there are wells implemented that have a wider variety of Assets in them and I'm going to guess that there will be certain assets that the community will will will look at for for white listing once the Well's implemented and say yeah this is a it's a good choice you know it's a it's a well-known um token it's it's something that we feel comfortable with and there's probably going to be instances where the Dow will you know we'll we'll see an asset in a well and and they'll be it'll be proposed for a white listing and the town may say no we're not comfortable with it um so it's again it's a two-step process and it will be interesting to see how it plays out especially as that that um breadth of Assets in different Wells gets gets wider as those those opportunities to whel list become more um so interesting to see how it plays out so if I could just jump in for a moment and Answer Tyler be's question just sort of directly uh if you look at a lot of these updates that pizzan just rolled through like Whit list V 1.1 generalized flood generalized convert uh all of those things have to do with sort of uh generalizing bean stock to be able to integrate with multiple wh listed Wells so I think it is fair to say that it feels like a priority uh for bean stock and the development seems to be pointed in the direction of supporting uh multiple whitelisted Wells and I think in addition space Bean just sort of mentioned this in the chat but the ability to deploy any well with two ERC 20s uh through the Basin UI is being worked on currently and about to be deployed so um yeah just wanted to answer your question more directly appreciate that sweet readed Tyler Tyler asked an additional question I think Is there a usage for a Well that is not Whitelisted? it's an interesting one a good one um is there usage for well that's implemented in Basin but not WID listed um so I think the the short answer is probably it depends so obviously there is an advantage for a well to be whitelisted if possible you know if the Dow is comfortable with it and um you know the well makes sense to Whit list it it should be and and it would be there would be an advantage to um you know to those who participate for a variety of reasons based on how the well is set up I think that um there is there is an opportunity at least for um for Wells that aren't white listed if for no other re other reason than simply to facilitate usage of basin and you know really the the advantages to Basin are offered primarily when a well becomes or or when a when a particular yeah when a well becomes wh listed um because then you know the seniorage um the seniorage opportunities there and there's just again just generally there's more incentive to to participate in that well but the ability to implement arbitrary wells in and of itself there is there's there's opportunity that comes along with that I I I again I think this is something that we'll we'll probably see users take advantage of in ways that we probably can't um you know fully anticipate right now but yeah there definitely is opportunity even for non-white listed Wells and pairs if I could just add on to that sort of one of the reasons why uh I guess the inspiration for Basin came from uh the understanding of multiblock me becoming possible after the merge and in theory any any protocol that wants to incentivize uh liquidity into a specific pool would be able to plug P multiflow which is the Oracle system built on top of basin and so I don't know if it's super clear exactly which sort of protocols would be the right fit uh to use something like that but presumably if there was some other protocol of the ethereum network that wanted to use a plug andplay Oracle system I think Basin is superior to the other dexes that are uh on the EPM so that's just my two cents but um I think that is a use for Basin uh for other protocols that might want to deploy Wells and not necessarily have them be wh lessed in beanock appreciate that okay any other questions or comments on beanock 3 okay um so I've got a slide in here it says subgraph other updates so King I want to give you a second in case there's any updates you want to give and then sweet red um appreciate you joining us um definitely would love to hear from you about any other UI updates that we haven't haven't talked already all right so uh yeah absolutely um kind of my main focus over Subgraph updates the last couple weeks um been working on kind of a few different things but kind of the main focus has been uh getting us onto defi Lama and um it's kind of a process were like most of the way there uh Basin actually just got listed I think um yesterday though B basin's listed and you can see like all the historical volume on there um but really the one that that it least I'm most excited about and I think obviously be Stu and um getting the the apys on there is kind of the last the last challenge that that I'm working through but once we get that set up uh I think that'll be that'll be pretty exciting um you know if if in the future like like how we saw over the last few weeks when um you know when eth was pumping and and the apy numbers were getting up there um you know if that situation plays out again it will be nice to to have us listed um on that side as well so yeah that's that's kind of what I'm focusing on at the moment but um I guess with regards to that another thing that I want to highlight with the apy is um as a result of I guess the the development work that needs to be done to get onto defil Lama um we'll also have um a pretty clean and convenient mechanism we can use to uh actually display to users uh like a personal apy or um based on like you know any kind of arbitrary simulation that that someone might want to um simulate like for example the current apys are fixed to just 24 hours 7 days and 30 days uh and they're using like whatever is the the current uh like average being mint over that period but we'll be able to have uh you know we can Envision a system with these new changes where it would be possible for a user to specify you know anything that they wanted to for for the different parameters that'll go into the calculation um and of course like you know with with seed gauge and how the the seeds like shift between the seasons and all that so yeah I think that'll be pretty cool um I mean I can't really speak too much to in terms of when that would actually be available uh like on a UI for people to kind of play around with but at least like the capability of calculating it and then uh you know having it on defi Lama that'll be that'll be coming hopefully in the next week but we will we will definitely see that's awesome appreciate that soil so um yeah that's I mean that is very exciting one of I know that there's been a lot of chatter around the Discord about again you know how can we get the word out about beanock and how can we get the apy in front of more people I mean def Lama is going to be a a huge step forward in that regard um so appreciate the work there yeah absolutely sweet red you want to walk us through any any additional UI information yeah sure um UI updates on my end sort of have spent the last week or so working on some ux enhancements to The Silo page a lot of it uh sort of hopefully contextualizing the seed gauge system right now you can see the seed rewards but it's sort of not clear what the bean to Max LP IO is what the mid and the max are and hopefully that will sort of assist users to be able to make efficient actions when there are more than one Whit listed well um as we get to see the optimal distribution of LP sort of in play and so shout out nzj for your questions and Discord those are helpful and helping me think through. ux and so look out for that and then I think in addition uh starting to think through what the ux should feel like for generalized convert generalized flood uh Lambda to Lambda converts and anti-lambda to Lambda converts so all of the beanock three stuff um that's sort of I'm hoping to sort of think through all of that together because it's all connected and that's sort of the next thing that I'll be spending my time on so um yeah those are the updates from my end appreciate it all right Tyler is typing we give you a moment to all right soing I believe this is this question is for you Tyler B Are there plans to integrate with other DeFi protocols rights are we planning to do more Integrations with D5 protocols like lending or dexes I I'll let you jump in SW King and then I've got a thought too uh yeah so I wouldn't say we have um anything planned at the moment I mean it's definitely something that can be looked into um I I I don't know if maybe if you have anything specific that that you have in mind I mean I guess when I see the question the one the one thing that that I think of is uh you know getting Bas in like on uh you know a DEX aggregator or something something of that sort so that you know if you go into to metamask or or whatever and you just click you know whatever swap button they have that that it would be able to Route things through there um that seems like something that that would definitely be good to to do at some point but yeah curious if if you have any other specific ideas or or um if Rex does either yeah and while Tyler is typing I'll mention yeah I think I alluded earlier that you know we've been having conversations with other other outside groups and something that I have been really uh interested during those conversations to see is to you know kind of uh do my best to make kind of objective comparisons between where I see beanock and Basin heading and you know some of the the features and options and opportunities that other groups offer and I know that there's that there's always a desire to get things done more quickly and get new features and and and and new components shipped quickly um but what has struck me you over these last few weeks with some of the conversations I've been in is how much more capable the system that you that is being developed around bean stock and Bas and how much more capable that will be um again that you know something that that really struck me was you know talking with a particular outside group and and thinking about tractor and the level of complexity that you know that will be able to be executed uh using the tractor system it's just it it's going to be it's going to be pretty exciting to see how how people use that that system once it's implemented and you know if if if a protocol that we talk to is excited about automatic trading you know to you know based on a particular price threshold um you know Market limit pricing and pricing and trading um tractor is going to offer significantly more Dynamic um opportunities for use so you know I'm really excited about what we've got coming together here and so when I think about like other lending or dexes um I I think what what we're going to offer through beanock and Basin is significantly better anyways but again those are just personal thoughts okay that's um that's all I have for the slides um I don't see anyone typing currently in the voice Channel chat um pulling up the Barnyard chat do not see any additional comments there I'll give just another moment so Tyler is typing I'll give you give you a moment there oh of course Tyler says thank you for asking all the or answering all the questions and I guess and I will I will definitely thank the contributors that helped because again you know appreciate their input giving a lot of additional color that you know that that I don't have so definitely appreciate you guys helping out so um all right I think Closing statements that's all we've got for today um appreciate everybody joining us uh we will get this recording up as soon as possible and actually I think it was I think it was whiz suggested uh getting um like doing uh threads a thread on Twitter um to talk through what's uh discussed during Dow meetings and some other things that uh I was looking at those comments with and I appreciate them and uh yeah I think we're going to figure out a way to start doing that so we'll uh we'll start getting that information out um we'll have a a thread out on Twitter as a recap for this meeting and we'll get to recoring out here pretty soon all right thanks everybody appreciate your time